Dialectics of Depression in Mourning

Many know the Father of Psychoanalysis, Sigmund Freud, but not many know its “mother” - Melanie Klein.

Melanie Klein was a pioneer in psychoanalytic theory and helped shape the field of object relations theory. She is known for her work in developing psychoanalytic play technique to study infant development and her theory of the depressive position and mourning.

According to Klein, in the early stages of development, an infant experiences the world through splitting - idealizing and demonizing primary caregivers. However, as the infant grows, they begin to integrate the good and bad aspects of these objects to form a whole. This process is known as the depressive position.

The depressive position is a pivotal moment in development where the infant learns to cope with the ambivalence of loving and hating primary caregivers. It involves the ability to mourn the loss of an idealized object and move towards a more realistic perception of the object. Klein viewed mourning as an ongoing process in which individuals confront and work through the anxiety created by the loss of objects. (Klein, 1940)

Klein’s work on mourning has significant implications for understanding psychological distress. The depressive position is not a stage that someone completes once and for all; it is a capacity revisited throughout life. It concerns bearing love and hate toward the same person, and the guilt, concern, and wish for reparation that can follow. (Klein, 1940)

This is the dialectical quality I find in Klein’s account: mourning involves a relationship to both the good and bad aspects of significant others, rather than a demand to choose one picture. A parent may not have been everything we hoped, or everything we feared. Making that ambivalence thinkable can alter the authority of an idealized image. This is not advice to intensify depression or endure it without treatment. Clinical depression deserves careful attention.

Please take depressed feelings seriously and seek professional support if you are struggling or feel unsafe.

Klein, M. (1940). Mourning and its Relation to Manic-Depressive States. In Love, Guilt and Reparation and Other Works 1921–1945.

Previous
Previous

The Use of Transitional Objects in Mourning

Next
Next

The Lost Object